Why Is Jersey Mike's So Soggy And How Can You Prevent A Ruined Sub?

Jersey Mike's is a favorite on the fresh-made sandwich scene. Some of the chain's offerings are better than others, but there's a lot to choose from, and it's worth getting your order just right. One common problem with the subs, however, appears to be sogginess. As one Reddit user said, "I like the juice, but every time I try to order light vinegar and oil, my sandwich comes swimming in it. I tried to be super specific today with my order and say '[two] shakes only of oil and vinegar,' but it's still just as wet and sloppy."

As a remedy for a soggy sandwich, one simple tip may help: You can get the oil and vinegar on the side in a cup, and pour on as much as you want. You can even add a few dried Italian herbs to the oil and vinegar blend or up the spice and crunch with some killer giardiniera when you get it home. Now you never have to worry about a waterlogged sub ruining your lunch again.

There are some customer habits that Jersey Mike's employees can't stand, but this doesn't appear to be one of them. On Reddit, a self-identified Jersey Mike's worker said that employees were asked for oil and vinegar on the side so frequently that they already had premade cups ready to go — meaning it should be a simple request. Furthermore, when you're getting your sandwich to go, the amount of extra liquid poured on it may not matter; it could still end up soggy by the time you get it home. So, go with SOS, a food industry term for "sauce on the side," and request condiments, such as mayo, in to-go cups, too. Just think of it as "save our sub."

For more anti-sog suggestions, consider avoiding watery toppings, like tomatoes, that will take a sandwich from dry to full-on Navy submarine — you can get them on the side and add them right before eating. Or, go for some crunchy banana peppers, which will add a little moisture but won't leak as much as slices of tomato. You might even be able to get your bread toasted, or use a barrier of cheese to protect it. But if you love oil and vinegar — whether you are eating your Jersey Mike's sandwich at the restaurant, the office, or home — you can easily avoid the sog. Just ask for the liquid ingredients on the side and add them right when you are ready to eat. And if you have leftovers, be sure to follow proper reheating advice to keep that sandwich crisp.